ReadyTeach

Correct Me If I'm Wrong (B1)

A content-based learner training lesson dealing with error correction.

by Glyn James

ESL, methodology, learner training, error correction

Back to the library

Loading board…

What’s in this lesson

Every slide, written out. The lesson itself is a board you present and annotate.

Slide 1

ONE-OFF LESSON · B1

Correct Me If I'm Wrong

Mistakes, corrections, and how you like to learn

Slide 2

Advice from the professionals

Talk with your teacher about each professional in the diagram.

Lawyer

Doctor

What kind of advice do people get from these professionals?

Estate agent

Personal trainer

Psychotherapist

Slide 3

Advice you've had

Look again at the five professionals on "Advice from the professionals". Answer the questions with your teacher.

Lawyer

Estate agent

Psychotherapist

Personal trainer

Doctor

1. Have you ever received advice from any of these professionals?

2. Whose advice do you think is the hardest to accept, and why?

3. Did you follow the advice you got?

4. Is advice easier to accept from a professional or from a friend?

Slide 4

Before you read

A student said these sentences. Each one has one mistake. Rank the mistakes: which needs the most attention, and which the least? Then answer the two questions.

A

I am agree with you about the price.

1. How often should English teachers correct their students?

2. What kinds of mistakes deserve the most attention?

B

My sister is embarrassed. The baby is coming in March.

C

He work in a big hotel near the airport.

D

I'm really boring at work this year.

E

Yesterday I go to the cinema with my brother.

MOST

LEAST

Slide 5

Reading 1: Stop, fix or keep going?

Read the text. Would you change your answers on "Before you read"?

When?

Many language teachers split speaking practice into two kinds. In accuracy work, the aim is speaking correctly. In fluency work, the aim is speaking easily, without stopping. Teachers usually correct more during accuracy work and less during fluency work.

How?

In a recast, the teacher repeats the student's sentence correctly. The student says, "I didn't went out," and the teacher replies, "Oh, you didn't go out?" In direct correction, the teacher says what the mistake is and gives the correct form. With a hint, the teacher helps the student find it alone: they repeat the sentence up to the mistake, give a questioning look or just say, "Again?" With delayed correction, the teacher notes the mistakes and goes through them at the end of the activity or the lesson.

Which mistakes?

Not all mistakes are equal. A mistake that stops people understanding usually deserves more attention than a small one. Mistakes a student makes again and again, and mistakes in the lesson's new language, are worth attention too.

Does it help?

In a well-known study of classrooms in Canada (1997), Roy Lyster and Leila Ranta found that recasts were the teachers' most common correction. But students often didn't notice them. Students fixed their mistakes more often after a hint than after a recast. Too many corrections can stop a speaker in the middle of an idea and hurt their confidence. Too few can let mistakes become habits.

Slide 6

Four ways to correct

A student says this sentence. Name the technique in each teacher reply: recast, direct correction, hint, or delayed correction? Then tell your teacher which one would help you most, and why.

THE STUDENT SAYS

"Last weekend I have seen a great film."

A

"Last weekend I...?" The teacher stops and waits.

B

"Oh, you saw a great film last weekend? Which one?"

C

The teacher says nothing and writes it in the lesson notes.

D

"Not 'have seen'. Say 'saw', because it's last weekend."

Slide 7

You and corrections

Answer the questions with your teacher.

1. How did your teachers at school correct your mistakes?

2. Do you remember a correction that annoyed or embarrassed you?

3. How often do you notice and fix your own mistakes?

4. Do you like it when friends or colleagues correct your English?

5. Do you ever correct other people's mistakes, in English or in your own language?

Slide 8

Love it or hate it?

Give your teacher some reasons for each side. Your teacher writes them in the boxes.

Why do some students like being corrected, while others don't?

They like it because

They don't like it because

Slide 9

Three students

Read. Which of your reasons from "Love it or hate it?" can you find here?

Bernard

Gabriella

Gloria

AN ENGINEER FROM LYON

A NURSE FROM NAPLES

AN ACCOUNTANT FROM MANILA

Bernard designs bridges, and at work people come to him for answers. In his English lessons, he feels like a beginner again, and he hates it. When his teacher corrects him, he often gets defensive. He explains why his sentence is fine, or says that people at work understand him perfectly. Sometimes he takes it personally, as if the correction is about him, not his English. He really wants to speak well for his next project, but he doesn't want to feel small.

Gabriella loves being corrected, but not all the time. For her, the conversation comes first, so she likes to finish her idea before any correction. She trusts her teacher to choose the important mistakes, and she doesn't need to understand every reason. She makes an effort to use every correction: she writes it in a notebook, says the sentence again correctly, and tries to use it in her next lesson. When her teacher corrects a small slip, she just brushes it off, and a few of those slips have become habits.

Gloria works long hours, and her company pays for her English lessons. Her lesson starts at seven in the evening, when she is already tired. When her teacher corrects her, she usually nods and smiles, as if she already knows. Then she makes the same mistakes over and over again. She isn't lazy: she is busy, and some weeks, English is the last thing on her mind. She plans to work harder on her English when her busy season at work is over.

Slide 10

Which student are you?

Bernard

Gabriella

Gloria

Use two or three of the useful phrases in your answers.

1. Which student are you closest to?

2. Have you ever studied with any of these kinds of people?

3. Many teachers find it difficult to correct their students. Why do you think that is?

4. What advice would you give Bernard, Gabriella and Gloria?

5. Has the way you feel about corrections changed since school?

USEFUL PHRASES

• take it personally

• get defensive

• make an effort

• brush it off

• nod and smile

• over and over again

Slide 11

Build your contract

Choose one or two in each section, or write your own. Say why, using the useful phrases.

When?

Which mistakes?

How?

A At the end of the lesson

B Straight away

C In the notes after the lesson

D At the end of an activity

A Mistakes I make again and again

B Every mistake

C Only the new language from today

D Only mistakes that stop people understanding

A Give me a hint to fix it myself

B Write it down and show me later

C Repeat my sentence correctly

D Tell me the mistake and the right form

What first?

Your part

A Pronunciation

B Grammar

C Word order

D Words and phrases

A Say the sentence again correctly

B Tell my teacher when it's too much

C Write my corrections down

D Read my notes before the next lesson

USEFUL PHRASES

• I'd rather you...

• Could you... instead of...?

• I don't mind if you...

• Please don't... unless...

• Let's try... for a month.

Slide 12

Our contract

Fill in the contract together, and agree a date to look at it again.

ERROR CORRECTION CONTRACT

When

Which mistakes

How

What first

Your part

Our signal (when I want to finish my idea first)

Review date

Signed (student)

Signed (teacher)

Slide 13

Homework

ON YOUR OWN

Look at the corrections from today's lesson. Write five true sentences about your life, using the correct forms. Then write one more sentence: which correction will be the hardest for you to remember, and why?

Bring your six sentences to the next lesson. It should take about 15 minutes.

Slide 14

TEACHER'S REFERENCE · SKIP OR DELETE BEFORE CLASS

Answer key

FOUR WAYS TO CORRECT

• A. hint (the teacher repeats the sentence up to the mistake and waits)

• B. recast

• C. delayed correction

• D. direct correction

BEFORE YOU READ a suggestion for the teacher, not a fixed rank: any order the student can justify is fine

• B. "embarrassed" should be "pregnant". This changes the meaning and can confuse the listener, so it probably needs the most attention.

BEFORE YOU READ (CONT.)

• D. "boring" should be "bored". This also changes the meaning: the speaker says they are a boring person.

• A. "I am agree" should be "I agree". The meaning is clear, but it is a common habit, so it is worth attention if it comes again and again.

• E. "go" should be "went". "Yesterday" keeps the meaning clear, but the past simple may be the language of the lesson.

• C. "work" should be "works". A small slip; the meaning is clear.