Slide 1
SPACE SERIES · LESSON 4
Dark Matter
and Dark Energy
A C1 lesson on dark matter and dark energy. Part of a series on space-related topics.
by Glyn James
space, dark matter, dark energy, physics, science, CLIL, CBLT
Back to the libraryLoading board…
Every slide, written out. The lesson itself is a board you present and annotate.
SPACE SERIES · LESSON 4
Dark Matter
and Dark Energy
Warmer: things you can't see
The world is full of things we can't see.
Task With your partner, list five things in the physical world that are real but invisible. For each one, write how we can tell it's there.
The recipe of the universe
Task Everything in the universe adds up to 100%. Split it between the three ingredients below. Agree on three numbers in your group and write them down.
Ordinary matter
%
Dark matter
%
Dark energy
%
Ordinary matter is everything made of atoms: stars, planets, gas, dust, you. Dark matter and dark energy are two things scientists can't see: the video will explain them.
Watch for…
Task While you watch, note down:
Three things dark matter is NOT, and the reason the video gives for each.
1
Three things we know for sure about dark matter.
2
Careful: just before the "NOT" list, the narrator says "dark energy". The list is about dark matter.
!
Video: What Is Dark Matter and Dark Energy?
What the video said
It's not…
Clouds of ordinary matter: we would detect them.
Antimatter: it would give off a telltale glow of gamma rays.
Black holes: they would violently disturb everything around them, and dark matter seems to be spread out.
We know…
Something is out there. It interacts with gravity. And there is a lot of it.
The recipe
The video: ordinary matter under 5%, dark matter about 25%, dark energy about 70%. The Planck satellite (2018): about 5%, 27% and 68%. The video rounds generously; Planck's figures come from fitting the standard model of the universe to a map of the oldest light in the sky, so they are estimates, refined as the data improves.
Ordinary matter 5%
Dark matter 27%
Dark energy 68%
discussion
Task Discuss as many questions as you can. Be ready to give your group's answer to question 2.
1. How much of the video could you follow? Where did you get lost?
2. Everything we can see is under 5% of reality. Does that disturb you or excite you?
3. Much of what we know about dark matter is what it is not. Is ruling things out real progress?
4. Should scientists call something "matter" or "energy" before they know what it is?
5. Would you rather know every answer, or live in a universe with mysteries left?
6. The video calls us "apes with smartphones". Is humility the right lesson here?
TEXT A
The missing mass
Task Read your text. Then explain it to your partner without looking: who, when, what did they measure?, and why did it point to something unseen?
In 1933 the Swiss astronomer Fritz Zwicky, at Caltech, studied the Coma Cluster, a swarm of more than a thousand galaxies bound by gravity. Using the measured speeds of eight of them, around 1,000 kilometres per second, he applied the virial theorem, which links the speeds inside a stable system to the mass holding it together. The answer was startling: the cluster's density would have to be at least 400 times greater than its visible matter suggested. If so, Zwicky wrote, "dunkle Materie", dark matter, must far outweigh the luminous kind. His figure was far too high, partly because the distance scale of his day was wrong, but the gap never went away. Few astronomers took it seriously for decades.
In 1970 Vera Rubin and Kent Ford published the rotation curve of the Andromeda galaxy: a graph of how fast stars and gas orbit at different distances from its centre. Outer planets orbit the Sun more slowly than inner ones, and astronomers expected galaxies to behave the same way. Instead the curve stayed flat: stars far from the centre orbited as fast as those near it, too fast for the visible mass to hold on to them. In 1980, with Norbert Thonnard, they showed the same pattern in 21 spiral galaxies. The simplest explanation: each galaxy sits inside a far larger, invisible halo of mass.
TEXT B
Seeing the invisible
Task Read your text. Then explain it to your partner without looking: what is lensing? What did the Bullet Cluster show? Who disagrees?
Einstein's general theory of relativity (1915) says that mass curves space, so light passing a massive object is bent. A total solar eclipse in 1919 gave the first test: stars near the Sun appeared slightly shifted. When the "lens" is a whole cluster of galaxies, the effect is called gravitational lensing: galaxies far behind it appear stretched into arcs, smeared or doubled. Measuring that distortion lets astronomers weigh the cluster, dark parts included, and map where its mass sits.
The most famous case is the Bullet Cluster, where two clusters of galaxies collided at high speed. In 2006 a team led by Douglas Clowe compared two maps.
NASA's Chandra X-ray telescope showed the hot gas, which holds most of the ordinary matter; it had been slowed by drag in the crash. Lensing maps from Hubble and ground-based telescopes showed that most of the mass had passed straight through, with the galaxies. Mass and ordinary matter were in different places. The team called it direct proof that dark matter exists.
A minority of physicists still prefer modified gravity. In Mordehai Milgrom's MOND (1983), gravity behaves differently at very low accelerations; it fits galaxy rotation well, but struggles with clusters like this one.
Build the case
Task Number the four clues from 1 (most convincing) to 4 (least convincing). Agree on one order as a group and be ready to defend it. Then discuss the questions.
Zwicky's cluster (1933): galaxies in the Coma Cluster move far too fast for the visible mass to hold them.
A
1. Can something nobody has ever detected directly still be good science?
2. No experiment has yet caught a dark matter particle. How long should scientists keep looking?
Rubin's rotation curves (1970s): the outer parts of spiral galaxies orbit as fast as the inner parts.
B
Gravitational lensing: clusters bend background light more than their visible matter could.
C
The Bullet Cluster (2006): after a collision, most of the mass sits apart from most of the ordinary matter.
D
If dark matter sounded strange,
dark energy is stranger.
The 1998 surprise
Task Read the text. Which part surprises you most?
In 1917 Einstein applied his new theory to the whole universe and hit a problem: gravity should make it collapse. So he added a term to his equations, the cosmological constant, a steady push that kept everything still. In 1929 Edwin Hubble showed that the more distant a galaxy, the faster it is moving away; its light is stretched towards the red, a redshift. The universe was expanding, and Einstein later dropped his constant. The physicist George Gamow wrote that Einstein called it the "biggest blunder" of his life, but the story rests largely on Gamow's word, and historians doubt Einstein ever said it.
Surely gravity was slowing the expansion down.
In the 1990s two rival teams, Saul Perlmutter's Supernova Cosmology Project and the High-z Supernova Search Team of Brian Schmidt and Adam Riess, set out to measure the slowdown using exploding stars of predictable brightness, Type Ia supernovae. In 1998 both found the same thing: distant supernovae were fainter than expected, so they were farther away than a slowing universe allowed. The expansion is speeding up. They shared the 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics.
Whatever drives it is called dark energy. The obvious candidate is the energy of empty space itself. But quantum theory puts that energy too high by a factor of about 1 followed by 120 zeros: often called the worst prediction in physics.
How sure are we?
Task How sure is the speaker that each claim is true? Give each one a number from 1 to 5. Agree as a group.
1 absolutely certain
2 quite sure
3 fairly sure
4 not very sure
5 not sure at all
1
It's been confirmed that the expansion of the universe is speeding up.
2
We're pretty sure there is about five times as much dark matter as ordinary matter.
3
Dark matter seems to be spread out in a huge halo around each galaxy.
4
Dark matter probably isn't made of black holes.
5
Some physicists suspect that gravity itself behaves differently across a whole galaxy.
6
Dark energy might be a property of empty space itself.
7
DESI's results hint that dark energy may be getting weaker.
8
What dark energy actually is? We have no clue.
Three endings
Task Read the four cards. Which ending is most likely, and why? How does the DESI card change your answer, if at all?
Big Freeze
Big Rip
If dark energy stays constant, like Einstein's cosmological constant, the expansion keeps speeding up forever. Galaxies drift out of sight, stars burn out, and the universe ends cold, dark and almost empty.
If dark energy grows stronger over time (a scenario first worked out in 2003), the expansion runs away. Galaxies, solar systems, planets and finally atoms are torn apart in a finite time.
Big Crunch
The twist: DESI
If dark energy fades away or even reverses, gravity could win. The expansion would stop and reverse, and everything would fall back into a hot, dense state: the Big Bang in reverse.
The Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument is mapping millions of galaxies across 11 billion years. Its results in 2024 and 2025 hint that dark energy may be weakening. But the signal is below the "5 sigma" physicists require for a discovery. A weakening dark energy would make a Big Rip less likely; it doesn't necessarily mean a Big Crunch.
Your verdict
Task As a group, choose the ending you would bet on: Big Freeze, Big Rip or Big Crunch. Prepare a one-minute case. Use at least three phrases from "How sure are we?".
A
A real substance that nobody has caught yet.
B
A sign that our theory of gravity is wrong.
Homework Explain dark matter or dark energy to a five-year-old. Record a 60-second voice note or write about 100 words, and send it to your teacher before the next lesson.