Slide 1
SPACE SERIES · LESSON 7
The Challenges of
Living on Mars
A C1 content-based lesson on the challenges of living on Mars.
by Glyn James
speaking, space, Mars, science, reading, advanced, CLIL, CBLT
Back to the libraryLoading board…
Every slide, written out. The lesson itself is a board you present and annotate.
SPACE SERIES · LESSON 7
The Challenges of
Living on Mars
Mars in pictures
1. What can you see in the pictures?
2. How impressed are you by such photos?
3. How many times do you think we've sent things to Mars?
Sixty years of Mars
Task Read the timeline.
1965 NASA's Mariner 4 flies past Mars and sends home the first close-up photos of another planet.
2014 India's Mangalyaan reaches Mars orbit at the first attempt, on a famously small budget.
1971 The Soviet Mars 3 makes the first soft landing on Mars, but falls silent within seconds.
2021 The UAE's Hope probe enters orbit: the first mission to another planet by an Arab country.
1976 NASA's Viking 1 lands and sends the first clear photo from the surface: its own footpad.
2021 China's Tianwen-1 orbits, lands and drives a rover, Zhurong, on its first independent Mars mission.
1997 NASA's Sojourner, the size of a microwave oven, becomes the first rover on another planet.
2021 NASA's Ingenuity makes the first powered flight on another planet; MOXIE makes oxygen from Martian air.
2003 Mars Express, Europe's first Mars mission, reaches orbit; its British-built lander, Beagle 2, is lost.
2026 Japan's MMX sets off to bring a sample home from Phobos, a small moon of Mars.
2004 NASA's twin rovers Spirit and Opportunity land; Opportunity, built for about 90 days, lasts over 14 years.
2027 planned: NASA's twin ESCAPADE probes, built by Rocket Lab, reach Mars to study its thinning air.
2008 NASA's Phoenix scrapes up water ice near the north pole and finds toxic salts in the soil.
2028 planned: launches of China's Tianwen-3, ESA's Rosalind Franklin rover and NASA's nuclear-powered SR-1 Freedom.
2012 NASA's car-sized Curiosity rover is lowered to the ground on cables from a hovering rocket platform.
2031 planned: Tianwen-3 aims to bring the first soil and rock from the Martian surface to Earth.
discussion
1. Which milestone on the timeline matters most, and why?
2. Look at the planned entries. How closely will you be paying attention to these events?
3. Nothing is mentioned about planned manned missions. Will we see it in our lifetimes?
4. "Sending people to Mars is a completely unnecessary risk. Let the robots do all the work until it's 100% safe!" To what extent do you agree?
How on Earth do we even get to Mars?
What are some of the biggest difficulties in terms of logistics?
The long way round
Earth and Mars both circle the Sun, but at different speeds, so the distance between them keeps changing: from about 55 million to 400 million kilometres. The cheapest route opens for only a few weeks every 26 months, when the planets are well placed. This is a launch window. Leave inside it, and the journey takes about seven to nine months. Miss it, and you wait more than two years for the next one.
The same rule applies on the way home. A crew that lands cannot simply turn round: it must wait on Mars, often for well over a year, until the return window opens. A round trip would take roughly two and a half to three years.
Landing is the next problem. Mars has enough air to burn up a spacecraft as it arrives, but too little to slow a heavy one with parachutes alone. The largest rovers sent so far weigh about a tonne; a crewed landing would need tens of tonnes, probably slowed by retropropulsion: rocket engines firing forwards, against the direction of travel, to brake.
Then there is supply: every kilogram of food, water, air, medicine and spare parts must be launched from Earth or made on Mars. Finally, radio signals take between about 3 and 22 minutes to reach Mars, and the same again to come back. This signal delay rules out a live conversation with Earth. In an emergency, the crew is on its own.
discussion
1. Send the habitat and supplies two years before the crew, or everything together? Which is better?
2. You can take 2kg of personal things. What goes in your bag?
3. With a 20-minute delay, who should make big decisions: the crew or mission control?
4. Would a one-way trip, with no plan to return, ever be acceptable?
what environmental difficulties would humans on mars face?
Thin air, hard light
Mars does have air, but it is about 95% carbon dioxide and so thin that the pressure at the surface is less than 1% of Earth's. At that pressure, the water in an unprotected person's mouth would boil at body temperature. Every home on Mars would have to be a sealed, pressurised shell, holding air at a pressure the body can survive.
The average temperature is about minus 60 degrees Celsius. A summer afternoon near the equator can reach about 20 degrees, but the thin air holds so little heat that nights are bitter: in Gale Crater, Curiosity has measured air near freezing by day and about minus 70 before dawn.
Earth is shielded by its magnetic field, an invisible barrier that turns away many charged particles from the Sun and deep space. Mars lost its global field billions of years ago. Curiosity found that the surface receives about 0.67 millisieverts, a unit of radiation harm, every day. A full mission, journeys included, would add up to about one sievert, a dose linked to about a 5% higher risk of fatal cancer.
Every few years, dust storms grow until they circle the planet. In 2018 one hid the Sun from the solar-powered rover Opportunity for so long that it never woke up. The soil holds perchlorates, salts that can harm the thyroid, a gland that controls how the body uses energy. And gravity is only 38% of Earth's.
discussion
Task Together number the six hazards from 1 (hardest to solve) to 6 (easiest). Then discuss the questions.
A
Thin air: almost no pressure, no oxygen to breathe
B
The cold, and the big swing between day and night
C
Radiation, with no global magnetic field
D
Dust storms that can hide the Sun for weeks
1. Which hazard matters little for a short visit but a lot for a permanent settlement?
2. Should the first crews live underground to block radiation, even if they rarely see the sky?
E
Toxic perchlorates in the soil and dust
F
Low gravity, 38% of Earth's
what other biological / anatomical problems would we face?
The body far from home
Almost everything we know about long spaceflight comes from stations orbiting Earth and from tests on the ground, not from Mars.
Some changes were expected. With no gravity to work against, bones and muscles weaken: astronauts lose about 1 to 1.5% of the density of their hip and spine bones every month, despite two hours of exercise a day.
Others were not. In weightlessness, body fluids shift towards the head, and many astronauts come back with changes to their eyes: a swollen nerve at the back of the eye, a slightly flattened eyeball, sometimes weaker sight. This is spaceflight-associated neuro-ocular syndrome, or SANS, and about two thirds of long-stay astronauts show early signs.
The immune system, the body's defence against infection, changes too. Viruses that hide quietly in most people for life, such as those behind cold sores and chickenpox, wake up again in more than half of astronauts, usually without symptoms.
In NASA's Twins Study, Scott Kelly spent 340 days on the International Space Station while his identical twin, Mark, stayed on Earth. Over 90% of the changes in how Scott's genes behaved reversed after landing, but for six months he was slower and less accurate in some mental tests.
Sleep suffers: astronauts in orbit average about six hours a night, and in Mars-500, a 520-day isolation test in Moscow, one crew member drifted onto a 25-hour day. Nobody yet knows how bodies cope with years at 38% gravity, or whether a pregnancy or a child's growth would be safe there.
discussion
Task Read the scenario. Choose A, B or C with your partner and give reasons. If you have time, discuss the questions.
The request
Some years from now, a six-person base is running on Mars. Two of the crew, a married couple, ask for permission to have a child there. Nobody knows how a pregnancy, or a child's growth, would go at 38% gravity, and a full hospital is months away.
A
Allow it: it is their decision and their risk.
B
Refuse until there is research, even if that takes decades.
C
Allow it only once the base has a trained doctor, a birth plan and a way to send mother and baby home.
1. Can a volunteer really consent to risks that nobody yet understands?
2. Should the first crews be older people or the youngest and fittest? Why?
3. If a crew member falls ill, should the mission put the patient first or the mission first?
Would you go?
Despite the risks, there are thousands of humans who would love to go to Mars.
Can you understand this desire?
Do you know anyone who would want to go?
There have even been plans to make a 'Big Brother' type of show. Would you watch?