ReadyTeach

The Search for Extraterrestrial Life (C1)

A C1 content-based lesson on the search for extraterrestrial life.

by Glyn James

science, aliens, ET, CLIL, CBLT, space, advanced

Back to the library

Loading board…

What’s in this lesson

Every slide, written out. The lesson itself is a board you present and annotate.

Slide 1

SPACE SERIES · LESSON 8

Is Anybody Out There?

The Search for Extraterrestrial Life

Slide 2

Aliens on screen and page

With your partner, make a list of films or books that feature aliens. Then discuss the questions.

1. How were the aliens similar or different in each one?

2. Were they friendly, dangerous, or impossible to understand?

3. Which way of showing aliens did you like best? Why?

Slide 3

Is there anybody out there?

YES

NO

Slide 4

Seven unknowns and a lunchtime question

In November 1961, the radio astronomer Frank Drake gathered about a dozen scientists at Green Bank, West Virginia, to discuss a question few took seriously: could we detect another civilisation? As an agenda, he wrote the Drake equation on the blackboard. It estimates how many civilisations in our galaxy are sending signals we could detect, by multiplying seven factors:

1. how many new stars form in the galaxy each year

2. the share of those stars that have planets

3. how many planets around each star could support life

4. the share of those where life begins

5. the share where life becomes intelligent

6. the share of those that send signals we could detect

7. how long such a civilisation keeps sending them

The equation is a way of organising our ignorance: it breaks one impossible question into smaller ones. In 1961 only the first factor was known with any confidence.

Today more than 6,000 planets around other stars have been confirmed, but the last four factors are still guesses. Hopeful guesses give millions of civilisations; cautious ones give just one: us.

That gap sharpens an older puzzle. In the summer of 1950, at Los Alamos in New Mexico, the physicist Enrico Fermi was at lunch with colleagues who were joking about flying saucers. Accounts differ, but he reportedly asked, "Where is everybody?" The galaxy is billions of years old, so someone should have spread across it by now. This clash between expectation and silence is the Fermi paradox.

The proposed answers fall into groups. Perhaps intelligent life is rare, and we are alone or nearly so. Perhaps the others are too far away, and their signals have not reached us yet. Perhaps they are quiet, by choice or because civilisations do not last. Or perhaps we are not listening in the right way, or for long enough.

Slide 5

discussion

1. Which answer to Fermi's question do you find most convincing: rare, far, quiet, or not listening?

2. Is the Drake equation real science, or just a well-organised guess?

3. If we are alone in the galaxy, does that make life on Earth more precious, or lonelier?

4. In general, is the discussion of 'Are we alone in the universe?' a serious one in your country?

Slide 6

The search so far

What have humans done in the search for intelligent life?

Slide 7

Student A

Task Read your two texts. You'll summarise them for your partner.

Project Ozma: the first search

The Wow! signal

In April 1960, Frank Drake pointed the new 26-metre radio telescope at Green Bank, West Virginia, towards two nearby stars much like the Sun, Tau Ceti and Epsilon Eridani, both about eleven light years away. He named the project Ozma, after the princess of Oz, the distant, imaginary land of L. Frank Baum's children's books. Drake tuned his receiver to 1420 megahertz, the hydrogen line: the natural radio frequency given off by hydrogen, the commonest element in the universe. He reasoned that astronomers anywhere would know this frequency and might choose it to call out. From April to July he listened, for about 150 hours in total. There was one moment of excitement early on, a strong signal that turned out to come from an aircraft, but nothing else was heard. The equipment was simple and cost about two thousand dollars, yet Ozma turned the hunt for alien intelligence from science fiction into an experiment. It was the first modern attempt at SETI, the search for extraterrestrial intelligence.

On 15 August 1977, Ohio State University's Big Ear radio telescope, in Delaware, Ohio, was scanning the sky as part of a long SETI survey. Big Ear could not move: it let the Earth's rotation carry the sky past it, so it could watch any one point for only 72 seconds. Checking the printout by hand, a volunteer, Jerry Ehman, noticed a column of characters, 6EQUJ5. It recorded a powerful signal on one narrow frequency, like a radio station, close to the hydrogen line. Its strength rose and fell over exactly those 72 seconds, just as a signal from a fixed point in space would. Ehman circled it and wrote "Wow!" in the margin. The signal seemed to come from the constellation of Sagittarius, but it has never been detected again, and without a repeat no one can test it. In 2025, a team re-analysing the original data found it was even stronger than once thought. They proposed a natural cause: a cold cloud of hydrogen suddenly brightened by a flash from a magnetar, the collapsed, intensely magnetic core of a dead star.

Slide 8

Student B

Task Read your two texts. You'll summarise them for your partner.

SETI@home: millions of home computers

Breakthrough Listen and the new giant dishes

SETI, the search for extraterrestrial intelligence, means sifting enormous amounts of radio data, and in the 1990s scientists at the University of California, Berkeley, could not afford the computing power. So they borrowed it. SETI@home, launched in 1999, was free software that ran on volunteers' home computers while they sat idle. Each computer downloaded a small slice of data recorded at the giant Arecibo telescope in Puerto Rico, searched it for unusual signals and reported back. Within a year, more than two million people around the world had joined. The project became a famous example of distributed computing: one huge job shared out among many ordinary machines. In March 2020 the team stopped sending out work, saying it had analysed all the data it needed. Their final analysis, published in 2025, narrowed about 12 billion detections down to 100 signals worth a second look, and China's giant FAST telescope began re-observing them. The team does not expect any of them to come from aliens, and none has been confirmed.

In July 2015, the investor Yuri Milner and the physicist Stephen Hawking announced Breakthrough Listen: a ten-year, 100-million-dollar search run from UC Berkeley, the largest ever. It bought time on two of the world's biggest radio telescopes, the 100-metre Green Bank Telescope in the United States and the 64-metre Parkes dish in Australia, and later added MeerKAT, an array of dishes in South Africa. China's FAST joined the effort too: completed in 2016 and 500 metres across, it is the largest single dish in the world. In December 2020, news leaked of a candidate signal, BLC1, picked up by Parkes in 2019 while it was pointed at Proxima Centauri, the nearest star to the Sun. It sat on one exact frequency, like a human radio transmitter, and appeared only when the dish faced that star. A year of detective work, published in 2021, found dozens of similar "lookalike" signals linked to ordinary electronic equipment. BLC1 was almost certainly interference from Earth.

Slide 9

now summarise what you've read for your partner

Slide 10

discussion

1. After more than sixty years of silence, should we keep listening the same way or change the method? How?

2. Which of the four attempts was the best use of time and money?

3. Should a possible signal be made public before it has been checked?

4. What do you think is the probability of our methods finding something a) in our lifetime, b) in the next 1,000 years, c) in the next 10,000 years?

Slide 11

Should we be looking?

Should we even be looking for intelligent life? Why do some people say no?

Slide 12

Listen: reasons for caution

Listen for the reasons people give for not searching, or for not replying.

Slide 13

discussion

What is the Dark Forest theory?

"Humans are nice, but humanity is horrible." How fair is that assessment?

"A civilisation that is capable of travelling the galaxy will also have an evolved morality - we have nothing to fear." How fair is that assessment?

The Dark Forest theory was popularised by the Chinese sci-fi writer Liu Cixin. Have you heard of this author? Can sci-fi offer meaningful solution to difficult questions in science?

Slide 14

Message in the dark

1. Has this lesson changed your answer to "Is there anybody out there?" Why, or why not?

2. If a confirmed signal arrived tomorrow, would anything in your own life change?

3. Would you rather know for certain that we are alone, or never know at all?